Horsetooth Tavern Menu

Updated: 2026
Price range: $10–20
Restaurant

Welcome to Horsetooth Tavern, a hidden gem nestled between Loveland and Fort Collins, Colorado. This inviting spot offers a delightful menu that caters to every palate, making it a must-visit for locals and travelers alike. The ambiance is relaxed yet vibrant, often complemented by live music performances, creating the perfect atmosphere for a memorable evening.

  • Signature Dishes: Don't miss the prime rib, cooked to perfection, and the barbecue wings, which earn rave reviews for their generous portions.
  • Unique Specials: Keep an eye out for the chef's specials, like the gnocchi or the elk sandwich with pickled onions, a fusion of flavors that excite the senses.
  • Decadent Desserts: Save room for dessert; the chocolate cake is a crowd favorite, promising to be the sweetest ending to your meal.

With its warm service and delicious offerings, Horsetooth Tavern invites you to enjoy a culinary journey right by the picturesque reservoir. Come for the food, stay for the friendly faces!

Browse Menu Categories (31)

Horsetooth Tavern Menu - 1
Horsetooth Tavern Menu - 2
Horsetooth Tavern Menu - 3
Horsetooth Tavern Menu - 4
Horsetooth Tavern Menu - 5
Horsetooth Tavern Menu - 6
Horsetooth Tavern Menu - 7
Horsetooth Tavern Menu - 8

Popular Picks

Bloody Mary
Bloody Mary
Cowboy BBQ Bacon Burger
Cowboy BBQ Bacon Burger
House Side Salad
House Side Salad
Kids Grilled Cheese
Kids Grilled Cheese
Fried Cheese Burger
Fried Cheese Burger
Mushroom Onion and Swiss
Mushroom Onion and Swiss
Burger with Bacon and Blue Cheese
Burger with Bacon and Blue Cheese
Chicken Wings
Chicken Wings
View full category

More Menus Near Horsetooth Tavern

Captain Hook Seafood
restaurant
Captain Hook Seafood

2880 E Harmony Rd, Fort Collins, CO 80528, United States

Are you the owner?

Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.

Claim this page Claim this page